Who should I start: Geno Smith, Michael Penix Jr., or J.J. McCarthy?

Week 7 · 2026 · PPR

Options in this poll

Geno Smith — 65 recorded votes
Michael Penix Jr. — 48 recorded votes
J.J. McCarthy — 8 recorded votes

Recorded result: Geno Smith led with 65 of 121 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

55% of analysts (58 of 106) favored Geno Smith. 55% of analysts (58 of 106) picked the winner, Geno Smith (23.7 pts).

Geno Smith: 58 of 106 analysts (23.7 pts)
Michael Penix Jr.: 42 of 106 analysts (20.4 pts)
J.J. McCarthy: 6 of 106 analysts (8.2 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion