Who should I start: Michael Penix Jr., Drew Lock, J.J. McCarthy, Geno Smith, or Gardner Minshew II?
Week 9 · 2026 · 4pt passing · 0.5 PPR · Redraft
Who picked whom
56% of analysts (50 of 90) favored Michael Penix Jr.. 56% of analysts (50 of 90) picked the winner, Michael Penix Jr. (15.5 pts).
- Michael Penix Jr.: 50 of 90 analysts (15.5 pts)
- Drew Lock: 19 of 90 analysts (12.6 pts)
- J.J. McCarthy: 18 of 90 analysts (4.4 pts)
- Geno Smith: 3 of 90 analysts (3.2 pts)
- Gardner Minshew II: 0 of 90 analysts (4.8 pts)
Question context
Lost Lamar and there was a huge run on QBs. These are my remaining options