Who should I start: J.J. McCarthy, Tyler Shough, or Kirk Cousins?

Week 16 · 2025 · Redraft · 0.5 PPR

Options in this poll

J.J. McCarthy — 33 recorded votes
Tyler Shough — 24 recorded votes
Kirk Cousins — 7 recorded votes

Recorded result: J.J. McCarthy led with 33 of 64 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

53% of analysts (31 of 58) favored J.J. McCarthy. 5% of analysts (3 of 58) picked the winner, Kirk Cousins (18.9 pts).

J.J. McCarthy: 31 of 58 analysts (8.4 pts)
Tyler Shough: 24 of 58 analysts (15.3 pts)
Kirk Cousins: 3 of 58 analysts (18.9 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion