Who should I start at QB this week: Geno Smith, Tyler Shough or J.J. McCarthy?
Week 7 · 2026 · 0.5 PPR · Redraft
What's behind this poll
49 analysts, including CBS Sports, Harris Football, ESPN, Boris Chen and FF Analytics, have weighed in. Pro Insights reads 14 analyst projections, 9 news articles and weather for 1 game.
See who picked whom
90% of analysts (44 of 49) favored Tyler Shough.
- Tyler Shough: 44 of 49 analysts
- Geno Smith: 4 of 49 analysts
- J.J. McCarthy: 1 of 49 analysts
Question context
Bye-week QB fill-in: Geno vs MIA, Shough vs PIT, McCarthy vs HOU.