Who should I start: Aaron Rodgers, Michael Penix Jr., or Justin Herbert?

Week 5 · 2026

Options in this poll

Aaron Rodgers — 84 recorded votes
Michael Penix Jr. — 6 recorded votes
Justin Herbert — 4 recorded votes

Recorded result: Aaron Rodgers led with 84 of 94 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

89% of analysts (82 of 92) favored Aaron Rodgers. 89% of analysts (82 of 92) picked the winner, Aaron Rodgers (21.0 pts).

Aaron Rodgers: 82 of 92 analysts (21.0 pts)
Michael Penix Jr.: 6 of 92 analysts (12.7 pts)
Justin Herbert: 4 of 92 analysts (8.4 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion