Who should I start: Caleb Williams or Tyler Shough?

Week 6 · 2026 · Redraft · 6pt passing · PPR

Options in this poll

Caleb Williams — 77 recorded votes
Tyler Shough — 33 recorded votes

Recorded result: Caleb Williams led with 77 of 110 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

71% of analysts (75 of 106) favored Caleb Williams. 29% of analysts (31 of 106) picked the winner, Tyler Shough (33.0 pts).

Caleb Williams: 75 of 106 analysts (15.0 pts)
Tyler Shough: 31 of 106 analysts (33.0 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion