Poll Sports Start/Sit Trades Waivers Players Baker Mayfield fantasy football advice Baker Mayfield (QB, TB) appears in 94 polls on Poll Sports in 2026 (89 start/sit, 1 drop/add, 2 trade, 2 waiver wire), with 9,067 recorded votes.
Baker Mayfield start/sit results in 2026 In 34 recent scored start/sit polls in 2026, Baker Mayfield got the most votes 10 times and outscored the other options 8 times. The most-voted pick scored the most points in 20 of 34. Points use each poll's league scoring settings.
Week 9: Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith most votes: Baker Mayfield (74 of 109); Baker Mayfield 10.0 pts, Geno Smith 3.2 pts Week 9: Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith or Justin Herbert most votes: Baker Mayfield (69 of 106); Baker Mayfield 10.0 pts, Geno Smith 3.2 pts, Justin Herbert 8.4 pts Week 9: Baker Mayfield or Carson Wentz or Geno Smith or Justin Herbert or Joe Milton most votes: Baker Mayfield (46 of 105); Baker Mayfield 10.0 pts, Carson Wentz 0.6 pts, Geno Smith 3.2 pts, Justin Herbert 8.4 pts, Joe Milton 9.1 pts Week 8: Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith most votes: Geno Smith (75 of 103); Geno Smith 18.3 pts, Baker Mayfield 1.2 pts Week 8: Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold most votes: Sam Darnold (73 of 95); Sam Darnold 17.8 pts, Baker Mayfield 1.2 pts Week 7: Baker Mayfield or Cam Ward most votes: Baker Mayfield (74 of 98); Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts, Cam Ward 7.7 pts Week 7: Baker Mayfield or Tanner McKee or Tyler Huntley most votes: Tanner McKee (55 of 110); Tanner McKee 9.4 pts, Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts, Tyler Huntley 14.9 pts Week 7: Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith most votes: Geno Smith (78 of 101); Geno Smith 23.7 pts, Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts Week 7: Baker Mayfield or Tanner McKee most votes: Tanner McKee (50 of 98); Tanner McKee 9.4 pts, Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts Week 7: Baker Mayfield or Matthew Stafford or Aaron Rodgers or Geno Smith or Tyler Shough most votes: Matthew Stafford (103 of 106); Matthew Stafford 18.7 pts, Aaron Rodgers 11.4 pts, Geno Smith 23.7 pts, Tyler Shough 14.3 pts, Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts Latest 2026 polls about Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or Geno Smith? Week 9, 2026 · 109 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Baker Mayfield, Geno Smith, or Justin Herbert? Week 9, 2026 · 106 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Baker Mayfield, Carson Wentz, Geno Smith, Justin Herbert, or Joe Milton? Week 9, 2026 · 105 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Geno Smith or Baker Mayfield? Week 8, 2026 · 103 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Geno Smith Who should I start: Sam Darnold or Baker Mayfield? Week 8, 2026 · 95 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Sam Darnold Who should I drop: Dalton Schultz, Baker Mayfield, Juwan Johnson, or Tyler Shough? Week 8, 2026 · 14 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Dalton Schultz Week 7 QB: Baker Mayfield or Kyler Murray? Week 7, 2026 · 111 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Kyler Murray Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or Cam Ward? Week 7, 2026 · 98 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Week 7 superflex: Patrick Mahomes, J.J. McCarthy, Baker Mayfield or Jalen Coker? Week 7, 2026 · 107 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Patrick Mahomes Week 7 QB: Tyler Shough, Baker Mayfield or Tanner McKee? Week 7, 2026 · 107 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tyler Shough Week 7 QB2: Tyler Huntley, Baker Mayfield, Tanner McKee, Jacoby Brissett or Cam Ward? Week 7, 2026 · 98 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Week 7 QB: Tyler Shough or Baker Mayfield? Week 7, 2026 · 107 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tyler Shough Who should I start: Tanner McKee, Baker Mayfield, or Tyler Huntley? Week 7, 2026 · 110 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tanner McKee Who should I start: Geno Smith or Baker Mayfield? Week 7, 2026 · 101 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Geno Smith Week 7 QB (Allen on bye): Bo Nix, J.J. McCarthy, Michael Penix Jr., Tanner McKee or Baker Mayfield? Week 7, 2026 · 100 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Bo Nix Who should I start: Tanner McKee or Baker Mayfield? Week 7, 2026 · 98 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tanner McKee Who should I start: Matthew Stafford, Aaron Rodgers, Geno Smith, Tyler Shough, or Baker Mayfield? Week 7, 2026 · 106 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Matthew Stafford Who should I start: Baker Mayfield, Tanner McKee, or J.J. McCarthy? Week 7, 2026 · 103 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Week 7 QB: Tyler Shough, Baker Mayfield or J.J. McCarthy? Week 7, 2026 · 108 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tyler Shough Week 7 QB: Baker Mayfield or J.J. McCarthy? Week 7, 2026 · 97 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Earlier seasons Who should I start: Drake Maye or Baker Mayfield? 106 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Drake Maye Who should I start (pick 4): Aaron Rodgers, Anthony Richardson, Baker Mayfield, Cam Ward, or Dillon Gabriel? 11 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield, Cam Ward, Aaron Rodgers and Dillon Gabriel Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or Tyler Shough? Week 17, 2025 · 76 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Trevor Lawrence or Baker Mayfield? Week 17, 2025 · 76 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Trevor Lawrence Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or Jordan Love? Week 17, 2025 · 71 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or Kirk Cousins? Week 17, 2025 · 72 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield 