Who should I start: Baker Mayfield, Geno Smith, or Justin Herbert?

Week 9 · 2026 · PPR · Superflex/2QB · 10-team

Options in this poll

Baker Mayfield — 69 recorded votes
Geno Smith — 31 recorded votes
Justin Herbert — 6 recorded votes

Recorded result: Baker Mayfield led with 69 of 106 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

68% of analysts (67 of 98) favored Baker Mayfield. 68% of analysts (67 of 98) picked the winner, Baker Mayfield (10.0 pts).

Baker Mayfield: 67 of 98 analysts (10.0 pts)
Geno Smith: 25 of 98 analysts (3.2 pts)
Justin Herbert: 6 of 98 analysts (8.4 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion