Who should I start: Carson Wentz, Baker Mayfield, Geno Smith, Joe Milton, or Justin Herbert?
Week 9 · 2026 · PPR · Superflex/2QB · 10-team
What's behind this poll
68 analysts, including CBS Sports, Harris Football, ESPN, Boris Chen and FF Analytics, have weighed in. Pro Insights reads 12 analyst projections, 15 news articles and weather for 4 games.
See who picked whom
59% of analysts (40 of 68) favored Baker Mayfield.
- Baker Mayfield: 40 of 68 analysts
- Geno Smith: 23 of 68 analysts
- Justin Herbert: 3 of 68 analysts
- Carson Wentz: 2 of 68 analysts
- Joe Milton: 0 of 68 analysts