Poll Sports Start/Sit Trades Waivers Players J.J. McCarthy fantasy football advice J.J. McCarthy (QB, NYG) appears in 41 polls on Poll Sports in 2026 (38 start/sit, 3 trade), with 3,801 recorded votes.
J.J. McCarthy start/sit results in 2026 In 10 recent scored start/sit polls in 2026, J.J. McCarthy got the most votes 0 times and outscored the other options 1 time. The most-voted pick scored the most points in 7 of 10. Points use each poll's league scoring settings.
Week 9: J.J. McCarthy or Malik Willis or Kirk Cousins most votes: Malik Willis (85 of 105); Malik Willis 3.5 pts, Kirk Cousins 18.6 pts, J.J. McCarthy 4.4 pts Week 9: J.J. McCarthy or Kirk Cousins most votes: Kirk Cousins (88 of 99); Kirk Cousins 18.6 pts, J.J. McCarthy 4.4 pts Week 9: J.J. McCarthy or C.J. Stroud or Bo Nix most votes: C.J. Stroud (82 of 97); C.J. Stroud 36.4 pts, Bo Nix 17.0 pts, J.J. McCarthy 4.4 pts Week 9: J.J. McCarthy or Michael Penix Jr. or Drew Lock or Geno Smith or Gardner Minshew II most votes: Michael Penix Jr. (51 of 95); Michael Penix Jr. 15.5 pts, Drew Lock 12.6 pts, J.J. McCarthy 4.4 pts, Geno Smith 3.2 pts, Gardner Minshew II 4.8 pts Week 9: J.J. McCarthy or Kirk Cousins or Sam Darnold or Kyler Murray most votes: Kirk Cousins (75 of 116); Kirk Cousins 18.6 pts, Sam Darnold 0.0 pts, J.J. McCarthy 4.4 pts, Kyler Murray 0.0 pts Week 7: J.J. McCarthy or Jacoby Brissett or Tanner McKee most votes: Jacoby Brissett (51 of 108); Jacoby Brissett 15.2 pts, Tanner McKee 9.4 pts, J.J. McCarthy 8.2 pts Week 7: J.J. McCarthy or Baker Mayfield or Tanner McKee most votes: Baker Mayfield (49 of 103); Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts, Tanner McKee 9.4 pts, J.J. McCarthy 8.2 pts Week 7: J.J. McCarthy or Tanner McKee most votes: Tanner McKee (64 of 102); Tanner McKee 9.4 pts, J.J. McCarthy 8.2 pts Week 7: J.J. McCarthy or Geno Smith or Michael Penix Jr. most votes: Geno Smith (65 of 121); Geno Smith 23.7 pts, Michael Penix Jr. 20.4 pts, J.J. McCarthy 8.2 pts Week 7: J.J. McCarthy or Baker Mayfield most votes: Baker Mayfield (92 of 115); Baker Mayfield 6.7 pts, J.J. McCarthy 8.2 pts Latest 2026 polls about J.J. McCarthy Who should I start: Aaron Rodgers, J.J. McCarthy, Deshaun Watson, or Geno Smith? Week 10, 2026 · 47 recorded votes · open for votes Who should I start: Fernando Mendoza or J.J. McCarthy? Week 10, 2026 · 46 recorded votes · open for votes McCarthy or Nix? Week 9, 2026 · 97 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Bo Nix Week 9 QB: J.J. McCarthy or Malik Willis? Week 9, 2026 · 101 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Malik Willis Week 9 QB: J.J. McCarthy or Tyler Shough? Week 9, 2026 · 100 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tyler Shough Week 9 PPR QB: J.J. McCarthy or Drew Lock? Week 9, 2026 · 98 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy Jordan Love @ Patriots or JJ McCarthy vs Philly Week 9, 2026 · 101 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Jordan Love Who should I start: Malik Willis, Kirk Cousins, or J.J. McCarthy? Week 9, 2026 · 105 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Malik Willis Week 9 QB: JJ McCarthy or Kirk Cousins? Week 9, 2026 · 93 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Kirk Cousins Who should I start: Kirk Cousins or J.J. McCarthy? Week 9, 2026 · 99 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Kirk Cousins Who should I start: C.J. Stroud, Bo Nix, or J.J. McCarthy? Week 9, 2026 · 97 recorded votes · closed, most votes: C.J. Stroud Week 9 QB: Shedeur Sanders, J.J. McCarthy or Justin Herbert? Week 9, 2026 · 89 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy Which side wins this fantasy football trade: Cam Skattebo + DeVonta Smith + J.J. McCarthy or D'Andre Swift? Week 9, 2026 · 3 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Cam Skattebo + DeVonta Smith + J.J. McCarthy Which side wins this fantasy football trade: D'Andre Swift + Blake Corum or Cam Skattebo + DeVonta Smith + J.J. McCarthy? Week 9, 2026 · 2 recorded votes · closed, most votes: D'Andre Swift + Blake Corum Who should I start: Michael Penix Jr., Drew Lock, J.J. McCarthy, Geno Smith, or Gardner Minshew II? Week 9, 2026 · 95 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Michael Penix Jr. Which side wins this fantasy football trade: Blake Corum + Devaughn Vele or DeVonta Smith + J.J. McCarthy? Week 9, 2026 · 4 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Blake Corum + Devaughn Vele Who should I start: Kirk Cousins, Sam Darnold, J.J. McCarthy, or Kyler Murray? Week 9, 2026 · 116 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Kirk Cousins Week 7 superflex: Patrick Mahomes, J.J. McCarthy, Baker Mayfield or Jalen Coker? Week 7, 2026 · 107 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Patrick Mahomes Who should I start: Jacoby Brissett, Tanner McKee, or J.J. McCarthy? Week 7, 2026 · 108 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Jacoby Brissett Shough vs Pitt in Paris or JJ McCarthy @ Hou? Week 7, 2026 · 107 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Tyler Shough Earlier seasons Who should I keep (pick 2): J.J. McCarthy, Kaleb Johnson, George Holani, Pat Bryant, or Matthew Hibner? 24 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Kaleb Johnson and Pat Bryant Who should I start: J.J. McCarthy, Tyler Shough, or Kirk Cousins? Week 16, 2025 · 64 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy Who should I start: Matthew Stafford, Jaxson Dart, or J.J. McCarthy? Week 16, 2025 · 36 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Matthew Stafford Who should I start: Matthew Stafford or J.J. McCarthy? Week 16, 2025 · 30 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Matthew Stafford Who should I start: Patrick Mahomes or J.J. McCarthy? Week 15, 2025 · 36 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Patrick Mahomes Who should I start: Tua Tagovailoa or J.J. McCarthy? Week 11, 2025 · 84 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy Who should I start: Aaron Rodgers or J.J. McCarthy? Week 11, 2025 · 63 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Aaron Rodgers Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or J.J. McCarthy? Week 11, 2025 · 67 recorded votes · closed, most votes: Baker Mayfield Who should I start: J.J. McCarthy or Jacoby Brissett? Week 11, 2025 · 65 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy Who should I start: J.J. McCarthy or Tua Tagovailoa? Week 11, 2025 · 64 recorded votes · closed, most votes: J.J. McCarthy 