Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or J.J. McCarthy?

Week 11 · 2025

Options in this poll

Baker Mayfield — 62 recorded votes
J.J. McCarthy — 5 recorded votes

Recorded result: Baker Mayfield led with 62 of 67 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

92% of analysts (55 of 60) favored Baker Mayfield. 92% of analysts (55 of 60) picked the winner, Baker Mayfield (17.9 pts).

Baker Mayfield: 55 of 60 analysts (17.9 pts)
J.J. McCarthy: 5 of 60 analysts (10.0 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion