Who should I start: Matthew Stafford, Aaron Rodgers, Geno Smith, Tyler Shough, or Baker Mayfield?

Week 7 · 2026 · Redraft · PPR

Options in this poll

Matthew Stafford — 103 recorded votes
Aaron Rodgers — 2 recorded votes
Geno Smith — 1 recorded vote
Tyler Shough — 0 recorded votes
Baker Mayfield — 0 recorded votes

Recorded result: Matthew Stafford led with 103 of 106 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

97% of analysts (102 of 105) favored Matthew Stafford. 1% of analysts (1 of 105) picked the winner, Geno Smith (23.7 pts).

Matthew Stafford: 102 of 105 analysts (18.7 pts)
Aaron Rodgers: 2 of 105 analysts (11.4 pts)
Geno Smith: 1 of 105 analysts (23.7 pts)
Tyler Shough: 0 of 105 analysts (14.3 pts)
Baker Mayfield: 0 of 105 analysts (6.7 pts)

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion