Who should I start: Baker Mayfield or J.J. McCarthy?

Week 7 · 2026

Options in this poll

Baker Mayfield — 92 recorded votes
J.J. McCarthy — 23 recorded votes

Recorded result: Baker Mayfield led with 92 of 115 recorded votes.

Who picked whom

81% of analysts (79 of 97) favored Baker Mayfield. 19% of analysts (18 of 97) picked the winner, J.J. McCarthy (8.2 pts).

Baker Mayfield: 79 of 97 analysts (6.7 pts)
J.J. McCarthy: 18 of 97 analysts (8.2 pts)

Question context

Filler this week while QB ON Bye week.

Continue your research

View live poll and discussion